
You may find yourself in a potential dispute over damage to, or non-performance of a building or structure.
From an engineering perspective, there are two ways to resolve such a dispute:
In either case, you will need an engineer who is
An Expert Opinion is formulated in response to questions from the Court.
The purpose of an expert opinion is to provide a bridge between primary evidence and a conclusion that cannot be reached without the application of expertise (Ref 1).
This bridge requires solid factual foundations, formulated from careful consideration of primary evidence and constructed using the in-depth knowledge and experience of the expert.
The expert's opinion report presents the case facts and the assumptions made from those facts , and a well reasoned conclusion.
(Ref 1) Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar [2011] HCA 21, Heydon J.
Proof of assumption rule: For expert opinion to be admissible (under s 79 of the Evidence Act 1995 NSW), the expert must explicitly identify and prove the facts and assumptions on which their opinion is based.
Expert Engagements
CCP and COOEC v site Contractor [2009], Qingdao, China
Structural foundation failure.
Croft v QBCC [2025], QCAT 139, Oliver R.
Structural failure due to poor building practices.
Thompson v Awning Worx [2026], QCAT, Brown I.
Faulty construction, water penetration.
Georgiou Building v West Steel Sheds WA P/L [2017], WA Supreme Court CIV2870
Challenge to engineering design consultant
Incitec Pivot, 2024
Building collapse
Veolia, Expert Determination,2025
Extensive fire damage to process building